The October 7 Election Is a Battle for Israel’s Soul

For Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, October 7 is not about learning lessons and making improvements — but rather about placing the blame on the military.

Originally published in Svenska Dagbladet: Valet i Israel är ett slag om landets själ | David Stavrou | SvD Ledare

He has dominated Israeli politics for three decades. Few contemporary democratic leaders have accumulated as much experience and political skill as Benjamin Netanyahu. In Israel’s October 27 election, he is running for a seventh term as Prime Minister. But the question is, beyond the desire to hold on to power, does he have a clear plan for Israel, and in what direction does he want to take the country?

On this question, Israelis are deeply divided. Netanyahu’s critics see a skilled tactician whose main objective is political survival and who is now also trying to shape his legacy as what he himself calls “Israel’s defender.” They also argue that his political calculations cannot be separated from the ongoing corruption trial, which has now lasted six years. Netanyahu, who maintains that the charges are politically motivated, turns 77 a few days before the election and has also suffered from both cancer and heart problems. If he wins the election, it will become increasingly difficult to bring the trial to a conclusion.

His supporters, by contrast, see a leader with a long-term vision who has transformed Israel’s position in the Middle East and who has a clear strategy. In foreign policy, it's all about preventing the establishment of a Palestinian state between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea. Domestically, it's about reshaping institutions that limit political power, above all the judiciary – the Supreme Court and State Prosecution, and the established media.

A couple of decades ago, Netanyahu was still a classic right-wing politician — hawkish on defense, neoliberal and conservative. Something like a Middle Eastern Margaret Thatcher. Today he is more of a populist, and his former allies on the right have turned against him. Instead, he has allied himself with ultra-Orthodox and nationalist right-wing parties. The election will therefore be less a contest between left and right than between those who support Netanyahu and those who oppose him.

For many Israelis, especially Netanyahu’s critics, it is obvious that the first election after October 7 should be about the worst catastrophe in Israel’s history, the day that claimed around 1,200 lives and left thousands wounded, 251 people taken hostage, and entire communities destroyed and abandoned. They argue that the election debate should address questions such as why the catastrophe occurred, how it was handled, and which path the country should choose going forward.

October 7 was not a single intelligence failure, but the culmination of several years of weakening Israel’s political system and security apparatus. The IDF and the Shin Bet security service became trapped in the belief that Hamas had been deterred. Warning signs from intelligence agencies, border observers, regional actors, and suspicious activity on the night before the attack were misinterpreted or failed to lead to sufficient preparations. The military was weakened by organizational rigidity and excessive faith in technology. Politicians, led by Netanyahu, allowed Qatari money to flow into Gaza and acted on the assumption that the Palestinian conflict could be “managed” indefinitely.

The brutal awakening of October 7, 2023, came almost exactly 50 years after the Yom Kippur War. Then, too, information about the enemy’s plans was available, but the Israeli leadership was locked into a rigid conception of what the enemy would do and failed to prepare. After the Yom Kippur War, then-Prime Minister Golda Meir appointed a commission of inquiry and resigned the following year.

Three years after October 7, most of Israel’s military and security leadership have left their posts. Netanyahu, however, remains and has still not appointed an independent state commission of inquiry. He chose a different path.

For Netanyahu, October 7 is not about learning lessons and improving — but rather about blaming the military. His supporters also emphasize everything that happened after the catastrophe: the wars against Hamas, Hezbollah and Iran. Instead of taking responsibility, he is constructing a narrative that could win the “October 7 election”: everyone but him bears responsibility for the catastrophe, while he alone deserves the credit for the military successes that followed.

Are Israelis buying this account of reality? In a national security survey from June, only 20 percent described the country’s security situation as good or very good, just 29 percent said they felt a high degree of personal security, and only 15 percent believed Israel had won the war against Iran.

The dissatisfaction, however, has not translated into any clear shift in the opinion polls. Netanyahu’s right-wing bloc — Likud, nationalist right-wing parties and ultra-Orthodox parties — is relatively united. The opposition, currently led by former IDF chief Gadi Eisenkot, ranges from Netanyahu critics on the right through the center and the remnants of the Israeli left to Israeli-Arab parties. Much like a potential Swedish governing coalition based on the Social Democrats, Greens, Left Party and Centre Party, it would struggle to form a government because of internal red lines and major ideological differences. Unlike the opposition to Viktor Orbán in Hungary, the Israeli opposition lacks a united alternative.

The latest opinion polls indicate that the election will be close. But it is worth remembering that for many Israelis, the election is as much about who they are as what they think. The outcome may be determined by which of Israel’s “tribes,” as former President Reuven Rivlin defined them in a famous speech, mobilizes the most voters — secular, national-religious, ultra-Orthodox or Arab Israelis.

Between and within these groups, a profound struggle is underway over the country’s democracy and welfare. Israel today has an increasingly politicized police force, extremist settler violence in the West Bank, and an ever-deepening conflict between the government and the judiciary. At the same time, liberal Israelis’ relative demographic weight is declining, while the ultra-Orthodox community’s exemption from military service and low labor-force participation are increasing the burden on the working population and public finances. The healthcare system has fewer doctors and nurses per capita than the OECD average, psychiatric services are under extreme strain from the aftermath of October 7, many schools suffer from teacher shortages, and the cost of living is high.

From a European standpoint, it's important to remember – Israel is not only about war and peace. The country is now in desperate need of healing and reconstruction. Many Israelis see the October 27 election as a decision about the country’s character and direction. For them, this may be the last realistic opportunity to change the course the country has taken.

Hamas Planned Attacks on Targets Abroad, Israeli Intelligence Says

Arrests have been made in three European countries after Hamas plot for terror attacks in the Middle East, Africa, and Europe uncovered, the Mossad and Shin Bet said

Published in Haaretz (with Jonathan Lis): https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-01-13/ty-article/.premium/hamas-planned-attacks-on-targets-abroad-israeli-agencies-say/0000018d-0432-dd94-a9cd-46fe9dad0000

Three European countries arrested suspects allegedly involved in plans by Hamas to attack Israeli and Jewish targets abroad in December, the Mossad spy agency and Shin Bet security service said Saturday.

According to the agencies' statement, the arrests in Denmark, Germany, and the Netherlands are part of an ongoing intelligence investigation in various countries.

It said that Hamas tried to plan attacks on targets in the Middle East, Africa, and Europe, commanded by top Hamas leaders Saleh al-Arouri, Samir Findi Abu Amer, and Azzam Al-Aqraa Abu Ammar – all killed in a bombing in Beirut earlier this month. The arrests were made on December 14, and legal proceedings continue.

The planned targets included the Israeli Embassy in Sweden, the agencies said. While other European embassies were open and functioning normally in the weeks following the outbreak of the war, the embassy in Stockholm was completely closed, very strict restrictions were imposed on the movement and work of Israeli diplomats in the country, and consular services were not provided to Israelis living in Sweden except in very urgent cases.

According to the Mossad and Shin Bet, Hamas' activity in Europe included acquiring drones and running street gangs. The statement further noted that Khalil Harraz, the former deputy commander of Hamas' military wing in Lebanon, oversaw the activity in Europe.

He was killed in November 2023 in an attack attributed to Israel in southern Lebanon. Harraz allegedly used Hamas collaborators in Europe and members of the organized crime group LFT – Loyal to Familia – which was outlawed in Denmark in 2021.

Swedish Authorities Detonate Suspected Explosive Device Found Near Israeli Embassy

Swedish daily news site Expressen reported that the object found and detonated by police was a hand grenade. Israel's ambassador to Sweden thanked police for its swift response

Published in "Haarertz" (with Jonathan Lis): https://www.haaretz.com/world-news/2024-01-31/ty-article/.premium/swedish-authorities-detonate-suspected-explosive-device-found-near-israeli-embassy/0000018d-60c1-d897-a3ef-e3f9292e0000

Swedish police detonated on Wednesday a suspicious object found near the Israeli embassy in Stockholm, believed to be an explosive charge.

The Swedish daily news site Expressen reported that it was a hand grenade.

Israel's ambassador to Sweden, Ziv Nevo Kulman, said this was an "attempted attack" against the embassy and its employees, and thanked Swedish authorities "for their swift response." He added that they "will not be intimidated by terror."

Shortly after the attack, a police car and an officer with a weapon drawn were seen outside the Hillel Jewish school in the center of Stockholm.

Israeli Foreign Minister Israel Katz commended the Swedish authorities in a post on X for their "vigilance and quick handling of the attempt to attack the embassy in Stockholm." "Our excellent diplomats around the world are subject to danger and threats from supporters of Islamic terrorism. I told this to all my colleagues – Islamic terrorism must be eradicated everywhere. In Gaza and Europe. Defend your countries," he added.

"This is very serious. An attempted attack on an embassy is an attack both on those who work there and on Sweden," Swedish Prime Minister Ulf Kristersson said in a social media post, adding police and Sweden's Security Police were investigating "who is or who are responsible".

Kristersson said surveillance of the embassy and of Jewish institutions in Sweden had been tightened.

Aron Verstandig, chairman of the Council of Jewish Communities in Sweden, told Haaretz that he takes the incident very seriously. "I condemn this criminal act," he said.

Petra Kahn Nord, representative of the World Jewish Congress (WJC) in the Nordic countries, says she sees the attempted attack as very serious. "It is very good that the Swedish authorities acted quickly and decisively," she said. "Now I hope that whoever is behind this will be found and prosecuted soon."

Earlier this month, Israel's Mossad spy agency and Shin Bet security service said that three European countries arrested suspects allegedly involved in plans by Hamas to attack Israeli and Jewish targets abroad.

The planned targets included the Israeli Embassy in Sweden, the agencies said. While other European embassies were open and functioning normally in the weeks following the outbreak of the war, the embassy in Stockholm was completely closed, very strict restrictions were imposed on the movement and work of Israeli diplomats in the country, and consular services were not provided to Israelis living in Sweden except in very urgent cases.